# Spotting a Forgery Before You Bid: the Triage From Lot Page to Laboratory

> Source: LLB Auction (https://www.llb-auction.com/insights/the-saleroom/provenance-and-condition/spotting-a-forgery-before-you-bid-triage-from-lot-page-to-laboratory)
> Author: Lyna Brahami
> Published: 20 November 2026

---

You are scrolling an online sale when a Bernard Buffet oil appears at an estimate far below what comparable canvases have made, and you want to know which signs should stop your bid. If you guess wrong, you lose the whole price: in 2004 two collectors paid $8.3 million for a Rothko that Knoedler & Co had bought from its supplier for $950,000, and the painting was a forgery. Knowing how to detect art forgery before you bid turns that risk into a graded triage. You read the lot page first, you put three questions to the house, and you pay a foundation or a laboratory only when your stake justifies the fee. The first level takes you about ten minutes and costs you nothing, and the checklist further down this page runs on any lot you are watching.

> **Key points**
> - Your first two levels of checking cost nothing; a laboratory test starts under $1,000, and pigment analysis can cost tens of thousands of dollars.
> - Your decision rule: escalate one level for each red flag that the lot page and the house cannot clear.
> - Your next step: run the ten-minute checklist on the lot, then send your questions to the house before the sale closes.

## How to detect art forgery on the lot page

The lot page gives you four things to check before any laboratory enters the question. **Comparable results** are the hammer prices of similar works by the same artist: a 1966 Buffet still life in oil on canvas, 93 × 74 cm, sold for $127,000 in May 2025 against an estimate of $100,000 to $150,000. When an oil of similar size is estimated at a fraction of that figure, you need an explanation in the catalogue note, such as condition, a weaker period or a qualified attribution. If the note gives none, count the gap as your first red flag.

Your second check is provenance. **Provenance** is the documented chain of owners from the artist to the seller, and a line reading only "private collection" gives you nothing to verify. Wolfgang Beltracchi sold his forgeries out of an invented collection that his wife said had belonged to her grandparents and had been hidden during the Second World War. The 1966 Buffet sold in 2025 shows you the opposite case: its catalogue named the Paris dealers, the Chicago gallery, the buyer of 1967 and the original invoice.

Your third and fourth checks are the description and the signature. Compare the dimensions, the medium and the date with the **catalogue raisonné** (the complete illustrated catalogue of an artist's known works); for Buffet, Galerie Maurice Garnier records the paintings in its archives and issues the certificates that auction catalogues cite. In the Knoedler case, one purported Pollock carried a misspelled signature, and a microscope showed that another signature had been painted over a precise tracing of a genuine one. Compare the signature on your lot with signed works of the same years in published results, and count any mismatch as a flag.

> **Decision:** You are looking at an oil estimated well below comparable results, with a provenance line you cannot verify. If you bid on the lot page alone and the work proves false, you lose the hammer price and the buyer's premium; on a canvas comparable to the Buffet sold for $127,000 in 2025, your loss is a six-figure sum. Your stake separates the options: bid on the house's answers when the price stays within what you accept to lose, consult the artist's committee when the attribution carries the value, and add a laboratory when your bid exceeds the test fee many times over. Next step: run the ten-minute checklist below on this lot, about ten minutes, then send your three questions to the house.

## What each level of check costs you

Your first two levels cost you time and nothing else: the lot page is public, and your questions to the house are part of the sale. An artist's committee or foundation sets its own fee and delay, which you ask for before you submit the work. The laboratory is the most expensive level: tests start under $1,000, and molecular work such as pigment analysis can cost tens of thousands of dollars. Size the check to your bid, so that a test of $1,000 fits a lot of $30,000 and a pigment study of $20,000 fits only a six-figure bid.

| Level | What you check | What it costs you | What it settles | A forgery case where this level mattered |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. The lot page | Estimate against comparables, provenance line, dimensions and medium, signature | Nothing, about ten minutes | Whether the lot needs questions | Beltracchi: a collection invented as hidden during the war |
| 2. The house | Photographs of the verso and the signature, provenance documents, the specialist's examination in person | Nothing | Whether the paper history holds | Spoutz: a ZIP code printed on a letterhead dated four years before ZIP codes existed |
| 3. Committee or catalogue raisonné | Archive record, certificate, published entry | The committee's own fee | The attribution opinion | De Hory: copied certification stamps and photographs slipped into auction catalogues |
| 4. Laboratory | Pigments, binders, varnish | From under $1,000 to tens of thousands of dollars | Whether a material postdates the artist | Knoedler: paint materials developed decades after Pollock's death in 1956 |

![A painted signature under a loupe beside paint sample vials on a laboratory bench, gouache illustration](https://renderings.laboetie.io/media/LH9XhLBSUzMUlRpo0pN7D/w2560)

Elmyr de Hory's partner Fernand Legros copied the certification stamps of art historians and inserted photographs of de Hory's forgeries into auction catalogues and artist monographs, so a certificate alone did not protect the 40 paintings bought by the oil collector Algur Meadows and exposed in 1967. Beltracchi had most of his pigments tested himself, and one tube of white paint containing titanium white, a pigment unknown in Heinrich Campendonk's lifetime, exposed him; he was sentenced to six years in prison in October 2011. Our page on [laboratory tests on a painting](/insights/the-saleroom/provenance-and-condition/when-science-enters-the-room-testing-a-contemporary-work) explains what each analysis can date.

## Which check your bid needs: the ten-minute checklist

Run these six checks on any lot before you place a bid; together they cover how to detect art forgery from the catalogue alone:

1. Pull three comparable results for the same artist, medium and size from published sale results.
2. Read the provenance line and look for at least one named owner, dealer or exhibition you can verify.
3. Check the dimensions, medium and date against the catalogue raisonné or the artist's archive.
4. Compare the signature with signed works of the same years.
5. Read the condition report and the conditions of sale, including the remedy they give you as a buyer.
6. Write down every flag you could not clear.

Your count of flags decides the next level. With no flag, you bid on the lot page and the house's answers. With one flag, you send your questions to the house and bid only if the answers clear it. With two flags, or an unexplained price gap on a lot that matters to you, you ask the artist's committee before the sale closes, and you add a laboratory on a six-figure bid or when the committee cannot settle the question. Watch the cataloguing terms as well: Eric Spoutz sold his fakes as "attributed to" an artist, a lower rung that [the attribution ladder](/insights/the-saleroom/provenance-and-condition/the-attribution-ladder-autograph-attributed-to-studio-of-circle-of-follower-of) sets out term by term.

## If the work proves false after you buy

If you expect a refund when a lot proves forged, look at the largest cases on record: they took years and ended in partial or undisclosed settlements. Domenico and Eleanore De Sole bought their Rothko from Knoedler in 2004, sued in 2013 for $25 million in damages and settled during the trial in February 2016, on terms that were never disclosed; the gallery had closed in 2011. Eric Spoutz defrauded collectors of $1.45 million, and the court ordered $154,100 in restitution, about 11% of that sum. At LLB Auction you, the buyer, carry the authenticity risk, and the conditions of each sale state what remedy, if any, applies to your lot. Knowing how to detect art forgery before the hammer falls is the protection you control.

## How LLB Auction answers your questions before you bid

At LLB Auction the specialist examines every object in person before it goes to sale, so your questions reach someone who has handled the work. Ask for photographs of the verso and of the signature, for the provenance documents the consignor supplied, and for the condition report. Asking costs you nothing and does not oblige you to bid. The house states one reply time, 48 working hours for a valuation by Lyna Brahami, Associate Specialist; for a question on a lot, write as soon as the lot catches your eye so that the answer reaches you before the sale closes.

For your comparables, the house publishes the result of every sale since its first, with each lot and its hammer price, on its [2026 results page](/results/year/2026). The house gives no guarantee that a work is authentic, so you weigh its answers and the documents behind them against your checklist. When a flag remains, [send your questions to the house](/contact) with the lot number and the three documents you want to see.

## Conclusion: how to detect art forgery before the hammer falls

Run the ten-minute checklist on the lot, send the house your three questions on the verso, the provenance and the specialist's examination, and escalate to a committee or a laboratory only when a flag survives and your stake covers the fee. This sequence is how to detect art forgery at the lowest cost to you: about ten minutes of reading, then one message to the house before the sale closes.

**Further reading:**
- [The due diligence behind every lot](/insights/the-saleroom/provenance-and-condition)
- [Verifying a certificate of authenticity](/insights/the-saleroom/provenance-and-condition/certificate-of-authenticity-or-catalogue-raisonne-which-proof-counts)
- [Reading the back of a painting](/insights/the-saleroom/provenance-and-condition/the-back-of-the-painting-how-to-read-the-verso)

**Sources:**
- FBI, [Forging Papers to Sell Fake Art](https://www.fbi.gov/news/stories/forging-papers-to-sell-fake-art), 6 April 2017
- Reuters via Insurance Journal, [New York Art Gallery Settles Lawsuit Over Fake Rothko](https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/east/2016/02/11/398395.htm), 11 February 2016
- The Art Newspaper, [Why auctioneers are buying into forensics](https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2017/02/13/why-auctioneers-are-buying-into-forensics), 13 February 2017
- Winterthur Museum, [Treasures on Trial: Elmyr de Hory](https://treasuresontrial.winterthur.org/evidence/de-hory/), exhibition record
- Artlyst, [Wolfgang Beltracchi German Master Art Forger Completes Jail Term](https://artlyst.com/wolfgang-beltracchi-german-master-art-forger-completes-jail-term/), 19 January 2015
- Rago, [Bernard Buffet, Bouquet jaune fond orange, lot 146](https://www.ragoarts.com/auctions/2025/05/post-war-contemporary-art/146), 21 May 2025