# Artwork Damaged in Transit: Who Bears the Risk After an Auction and How to Claim

> Source: LLB Auction (https://www.llb-auction.com/insights/the-saleroom/how-auctions-work/lost-or-damaged-in-transit-who-bears-the-risk-on-an-auction-purchase)
> Author: Lyna Brahami
> Published: 19 November 2026

---

A buyer who searches for "artwork damaged in transit" with a broken frame already on the floor has passed most of the useful decisions. November 2026 put the question back on the trade's agenda: on 18 November a Mayfair silver dealer called on delivery firms to track valuable packages more thoroughly after items went missing in transit, ten days after a 1962 bronze by Jean Arp priced at €145,000 disappeared from a gallery stand at Art Cologne. This guide answers three questions in the order a buyer meets them: when the risk of loss passes from the seller's side to yours, what a carrier owes when a lot is lost or broken (about €61 by road for a 6 kg framed painting), and what you must do at the door and within days to keep a claim alive.

> **Key points:**
> - Under the CMR Convention, a road carrier owes at most 8.33 SDR per kilogram of gross weight for lost or damaged goods; on 18 November 2026 one SDR was worth US$1.343590.
> - Since 28 December 2024, an air carrier owes at most 26 SDR per kilogram for lost or damaged cargo under the Montreal Convention, up from 22 SDR.
> - Hidden damage must be reported to a road carrier within seven days of delivery, Sundays and public holidays excepted, and to an air carrier in writing within 14 days of receipt.
> - In a consumer sale where the trader dispatches the goods, EU law moves the risk to the buyer when the buyer takes physical possession, unless the buyer chose a carrier the trader did not offer.

## Why theft and damage in transit returned to the headlines in November 2026

Two incidents in the same fortnight of November 2026 show where a work is most exposed: on the move and in public. On Sunday 8 November 2026, a bronze by **Jean Arp** (the sculptor also known as Hans Arp) was taken from the booth of Galerie Ludorff at Art Cologne. The Düsseldorf gallery had priced the 1962 sculpture at €145,000 ($160,000), a criminal investigation opened, and the gallery appealed publicly for witnesses.

On 18 November 2026, the trade paper Antiques Trade Gazette reported that Koopman Rare Art, a silver specialist based in Mayfair, was asking shipping and delivery firms to track valuable packages more thoroughly after items went missing in transit from overseas. The losses happened between two doors.

Neither story concerns an auction purchase, yet both describe the risk every buyer accepts when a lot leaves the saleroom. The calendar adds weight to them: the November sales in New York, London, Paris and Luxembourg send their lots to new owners in the weeks before the year-end holidays. The figures that follow belong to treaties and directives in force in 2026; they will still apply once the Art Cologne case is closed.

What the two incidents share is a gap of hours or days during which nobody looks at the work. Every rule discussed below exists to allocate the loss that occurs in that gap: the conditions of sale fix the date the risk passes, the transport conventions fix what the carrier pays, and the insurance contract fixes what covers the rest.

## When the risk passes from the seller's side to the buyer

The **risk** is the burden of an accidental loss: whoever carries it absorbs the cost of a theft, a crushed crate or a cracked glaze that nobody can be blamed for. Ownership and risk are separate questions. A buyer who has paid in full owns the lot; whether that buyer also bears the loss if the van is broken into depends on the conditions of sale and on the law that governs them.

Every sale publishes **conditions of sale**, the contract terms that bind bidders, and every set of conditions contains a clause fixing the moment the risk passes. The formulas in use tie that moment to the fall of the hammer, to payment, to collection or to a date set a number of days after the sale. Read the clause of the sale concerned before you bid: the house's own conditions, quoted from the sale page, govern your lot, and a summary on a third party site carries no weight.

For a buyer who is a private individual in the European Union, a second text sits beside the contract. **Directive 2011/83/EU** on consumer rights, adopted on 25 October 2011, sets in its Article 20 the rule for goods the trader dispatches: "the risk of loss of or damage to the goods shall pass to the consumer when he or a third party indicated by the consumer and other than the carrier has acquired the physical possession of the goods." The same article adds an exception: when the consumer commissioned the carrier and that choice was not offered by the trader, the risk passes on delivery to the carrier.

That exception matters to collectors. A buyer in New York who asks the house to hand a painting to a shipper the buyer found alone takes the risk from the moment the shipper signs for the crate. A buyer who picks a carrier from the options the house proposes sits in a different position under Article 20. The Directive protects consumers only; a dealer, a gallery or a company buying for its business stays outside it, and the contract alone allocates the risk.

The Directive also defines a **public auction** in Article 2(13) as a sale that consumers "attend or are given the possibility to attend" in person, run by an auctioneer. Contracts concluded at a public auction lose the consumer's right of withdrawal under Article 16(k), and recital 24 states that online auction platforms at the disposal of consumers and traders are not public auctions in this sense. How a particular online sale is classified is a matter for its conditions and for the national law that governs them; in Luxembourg, that is Luxembourg law.

Two practical consequences follow. First, the moment of risk transfer is written down before the sale opens, and you can read it. Second, the buyer who chooses to ship rather than collect is the person best placed to insure the gap, because only the buyer decides the route, the carrier and the declared value.

## What a carrier owes when artwork is damaged in transit

A carrier's liability for artwork damaged in transit is set by the convention that governs the leg of the journey, and each convention caps it by weight. The work's hammer price plays no part in the calculation unless the sender declared a value in advance and paid for it.

The **CMR Convention** (Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road, signed in Geneva on 19 May 1956) applies to every contract for the carriage of goods by road for reward when the places of taking over and of delivery lie in two different countries, at least one of them a contracting country. A van from Luxembourg to Brussels or to Cologne falls under it. Its Article 17 makes the carrier liable for total or partial loss and for damage occurring between taking over the goods and delivery. Article 23(3), as amended by the Geneva Protocol of 5 July 1978, caps compensation at 8.33 units of account per kilogram of gross weight short, the unit of account being the **Special Drawing Right** (SDR), a basket currency defined by the International Monetary Fund and valued daily. Article 23(4) adds a refund of the carriage charges and customs duties paid in the case of total loss.

The **Montreal Convention** (Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air, concluded on 28 May 1999 and in force since 2003) governs air cargo between its States Parties, which numbered 140 in October 2024. Its Article 22(3) caps liability for destruction, loss, damage or delay of cargo per kilogram. The cap was 17 SDR in 2003 and 22 SDR before the latest review; on 18 October 2024 the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) announced a rise to 26 SDR per kilogram, about US$35, effective 28 December 2024.

"This Convention is fundamental in ensuring the protection of consumer interests in international air travel," said Juan Carlos Salazar, Secretary General of ICAO, when the revised limits were announced. "MC99 benefits passengers and the shippers of cargo while enabling the unified and equitable development of air services."

Parcel networks add a third layer. The terms and conditions of carriage of UPS for Europe and the United Kingdom state that packages must not contain "articles of unusual value (such as works of art, antiques, precious stones, stamps, unique items, gold or silver)". A painting sent through such a network travels in breach of the carrier's own terms, and a claim for its loss starts from a position of weakness.

Both conventions leave one door open. CMR Article 26 lets the sender fix "the amount of a special interest in delivery" against an agreed surcharge, entered in the consignment note; Montreal Article 22(3) lets the consignor make "a special declaration of interest in delivery at destination" and pay a supplementary sum. Either declaration raises the ceiling to the declared amount. Neither is automatic, and both must be made when the goods are handed over.

| Route or cover | Legal basis | Ceiling in 2026 | Deadline for written notice | How to raise the ceiling |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Road, across a European border | CMR Convention, Articles 17, 23, 26 and 30 | 8.33 SDR per kg of gross weight | At delivery if apparent; 7 days if hidden, Sundays and public holidays excepted | Declaration of special interest in delivery on the consignment note, against a surcharge |
| Air cargo, international | Montreal Convention 1999, Articles 22 and 31 | 26 SDR per kg since 28 December 2024 | Forthwith on discovery, 14 days from receipt at the latest | Special declaration of interest at handover, with a supplementary sum |
| Parcel network, Europe and UK | Carrier terms and conditions | Works of art and antiques listed as prohibited articles | Set by the carrier's terms | Separate written agreement with the carrier |
| Fine art transit insurance | Insurance contract | Agreed value of the work | Set by the policy | Agreed value fixed before dispatch |

## A worked example: a framed painting lost on the road to Brussels

Numbers make the gap visible. Take a framed oil on canvas sold in a timed online sale in Luxembourg for a hammer price of €4,000, with a buyer's premium of €1,000 under the conditions of that sale, so €5,000 before VAT. Packed in a cardboard box with corner protectors, the shipment weighs 6 kg gross. The buyer, a private collector in Brussels, books a road courier to deliver it, and the box never arrives.

1. **Applicable regime.** A road journey from Luxembourg to Belgium for reward falls under the CMR Convention, with the 1978 Protocol in force.
2. **Ceiling in SDR.** 6 kg multiplied by 8.33 SDR gives 49.98 SDR.
3. **Conversion to euros.** On 18 November 2026, one SDR was worth US$1.343590 and one euro US$1.09625, so one SDR equalled about €1.2256. The ceiling is therefore about €61.26.
4. **Refund of charges.** Article 23(4) adds the carriage charges paid, say €45, for a total loss.
5. **Recovery from the carrier.** About €106 against a loss of €5,000 plus VAT.
6. **Uncovered gap.** About €4,894 before VAT stays with whoever carries the risk at the time of the loss.

The same 6 kg sent by air under the Montreal Convention gives 6 multiplied by 26 SDR, or 156 SDR, about €191.20 at the rate of 18 November 2026. The air route triples the ceiling and still leaves more than 96 % of the invoice uncovered. A bronze of 25 kg sent by road reaches a ceiling of about €255; its weight changes the arithmetic far less than its price does.

The example contains one more lesson. Had the buyer asked the courier, before handover, to enter a special interest in delivery of €5,000 on the consignment note and paid the surcharge, the ceiling would have risen to that amount. Had the buyer insured the transit under a fine art policy at an agreed value, the insurer would have paid the agreed sum and pursued the carrier for its share.

## Deadlines that keep a claim for artwork damaged in transit alive

A claim for artwork damaged in transit depends on what the buyer writes at the door and in the days after delivery. Both conventions treat a clean receipt as evidence that the goods arrived in good condition, and both set short windows to rebut it.

Under CMR Article 30, a consignee who takes delivery "without duly checking their condition with the carrier or without sending him reservations" creates "prima facie evidence" that the goods arrived as described in the consignment note. **Reservations** are written remarks describing the damage, recorded at delivery for apparent damage and sent within seven days of delivery, Sundays and public holidays excepted, for damage that is not apparent from the outside of the crate.

Under Montreal Article 31, receipt of cargo "without complaint is prima facie evidence" of good condition. In the case of damage, the person entitled to delivery must complain "forthwith after the discovery of the damage, and, at the latest, within seven days from the date of receipt in the case of checked baggage and fourteen days from the date of receipt in the case of cargo." Delay claims allow 21 days. Every complaint must be made in writing, and Article 31(4) closes the door: "If no complaint is made within the times aforesaid, no action shall lie against the carrier, save in the case of fraud on its part."

The Court of Justice of the European Union confirmed the strictness of that rule in Case C-258/16, decided on 12 April 2018. It ruled that the complaint "must be made in writing" within the Article 31(2) periods, "failing which no action may be brought against the carrier", and that a complaint recorded in the carrier's information system with the claimant's knowledge satisfies the written form. The same ruling held that Article 31 imposes no substantive requirement beyond notice of the damage sustained.

Parcel networks set their own claim windows in their terms of carriage. Read them on the day you book, keep a copy, and work to the shortest window until you have confirmed the one that applies.

![Cracked corner of a gilt frame beside a crushed box and a condition report](https://renderings.laboetie.io/media/U6jltNARENZ9gfGBfsda3/w2560)

## Insurance that closes the gap

Of the instruments open to a buyer, insurance alone pays out on the value of the work. Three layers are available to a buyer, and each covers a different slice of the risk.

**Declared value cover** is the cheapest layer: the sender pays the carrier a surcharge to raise its liability to a stated amount, under CMR Article 26 or Montreal Article 22(3). It keeps the carrier's exclusions intact, so a carrier whose terms list works of art as prohibited articles can still refuse the claim.

**Transit cover under a fine art policy** is the layer collectors use. The Luxembourg insurers' association ACA (Association des Compagnies d'Assurances et de Réassurances du Grand-Duché de Luxembourg) describes fine art insurance in July 2026 as "nail-to-nail", meaning cover "literally from one nail to the other, where it will be displayed next", and as the standard for museums and private collections alike. The **nail-to-nail** principle covers packing, handling, transport and installation on an all-risks basis, with standard exclusions for war, strikes, riots, civil commotion, confiscation, nuclear, chemical, biological and radioactive perils, and wear and tear. Theft and mysterious disappearance sit inside the cover.

The same description lists two features that matter to a new buyer. Many policies grant automatic cover to newly acquired works for a defined period, allowing time for a formal appraisal; and a valid claim is settled by paying the agreed value, funding the restoration, or replacing the work where possible. Some policies add **depreciation in value** cover, which pays the loss of market value that remains after a successful restoration. Ask your insurer, before the sale closes, whether a lot bought at auction falls under the newly acquired works clause and from which date.

The insurer will ask for four documents after a loss: the invoice showing the hammer price and the buyer's premium; the condition report published with the lot; photographs of the work and of the packing before dispatch; and the delivery documents carrying your reservations. The condition report is the baseline. It records the state of the work before the sale, and any difference found at the door is the damage you claim.

Standard property insurance covers named perils such as storm, hail, flood and fire, and leaves the particular needs of fine art largely unaddressed. A buyer without a fine art policy can buy single transit cover from a specialist broker or ask a fine art shipper to arrange it at an agreed value, and compare its premium with the gap shown in the worked example.

## At the door: seven checks for a delivered lot

The evidence for a claim is gathered in the hour after delivery. The following checks, done in this order, preserve the evidence a carrier and an insurer will ask for.

1. **Inspect before signing.** Walk around the crate or box with the driver present. Note dents, punctures, wet patches, broken straps and tilt indicators on the delivery note before you sign it.
2. **Write reservations on the receipt.** Describe what you see in plain words ("corner crushed, glass audible inside"). A signature without remarks counts as evidence that the goods arrived intact under both conventions.
3. **Photograph the packing unopened.** Take pictures of every face of the box and of the shipping label, which carries the tracking number.
4. **Unpack slowly and keep everything.** Keep the outer box, the foam, the corner protectors and the glazing; the carrier's adjuster may ask to inspect them, and discarded packing weakens the claim.
5. **Compare with the lot record.** Lay the condition report or catalogue description and the lot photographs beside the work and record each difference with dated photographs.
6. **Notify in writing the same day.** Send a written notice to the carrier and to the house that sold the lot. For air cargo, write within 14 days at the latest; for hidden damage on a road shipment, within seven days.
7. **Leave the work as found.** After a loss, the insurer sends a specialised loss adjuster to assess the damage before any restorer is engaged; keep the work in the state in which it arrived until that visit.

Theft in transit follows the same discipline with one addition. A parcel tracked as delivered that never reached you, or a parcel that stops moving for days, calls for a written claim to the carrier and a police report in the country where the loss occurred. Both stories of November 2026 began with a work that nobody watched for a short window; tracked delivery with a signature on receipt narrows that window to a named person and a timestamp.

## Collect in person or ship: choosing the route for a lot

For a buyer within driving distance of the saleroom, collection removes the carrier from the equation. The buyer carries the work, wraps it and decides its route. The risk still falls on the buyer once the risk has passed under the conditions of sale, yet no weight cap and no complaint window stands between the buyer and an insurance claim.

For a buyer in Brussels, Cologne or Metz, a collection trip is a matter of hours. For a buyer in New York, Hong Kong or Dubai, shipping is the only realistic route, and the choice becomes one between a general parcel network, a freight forwarder, and a **fine art shipper**, a firm that builds crates to the work, trains its handlers for objects, and arranges transit insurance at an agreed value.

The price of a fine art shipper is justified when one of three conditions holds: the work is glazed, fragile or heavy; the agreed value exceeds what the carrier's weight cap would pay by a large multiple; or the route involves air freight, customs and an export licence. Works leaving the European Union may need an [art export licence](/insights/the-saleroom/how-auctions-work/art-export-licence-what-a-collector-needs-before-a-work-leaves-europe) before the shipper can collect them, and the paperwork adds days during which the work sits in storage.

Payment, collection and shipping arrangements for each sale are set out on the how-to-buy page of the house concerned and in the conditions of the sale; the step by step guide to [what happens after winning a lot](/insights/the-saleroom/how-auctions-work/after-the-hammer-invoicing-vat-customs-and-the-insured-journey-home) covers the invoice, VAT and customs that run alongside delivery.

## FAQ: artwork damaged in transit after an auction

### Who pays for artwork damaged in transit after an online auction?

The party that carries the risk at the moment of damage absorbs the loss, then claims against the carrier and its insurer. The conditions of sale fix when the risk passes. For a consumer in the European Union whose lot the trader dispatches, Article 20 of Directive 2011/83/EU moves the risk on physical possession, unless the consumer chose a carrier the trader did not offer. The carrier's own liability is capped by weight: 8.33 SDR per kilogram by road under the CMR Convention.

### How much does a carrier pay for a lost painting?

By weight, the price of the painting plays no part. A road carrier under the CMR Convention owes at most 8.33 SDR per kilogram of gross weight, plus a refund of carriage charges on total loss. An air carrier under the Montreal Convention owes at most 26 SDR per kilogram since 28 December 2024. For a 6 kg framed painting, that is about €61 by road and about €191 by air at the SDR rate of 18 November 2026.

### How long do I have to report hidden damage to a carrier?

Seven days by road and 14 days by air. Under CMR Article 30, reservations for damage that is not apparent must reach the carrier within seven days of delivery, Sundays and public holidays excepted. Under Article 31 of the Montreal Convention, a complaint about damaged cargo must be made in writing forthwith after discovery and within 14 days of receipt at the latest; after that, no action lies against the carrier except in the case of fraud.

### Does a fine art insurance policy cover a new auction purchase in transit?

Many policies do, under a clause on newly acquired works that grants automatic cover for a defined period. Fine art insurance is written on a nail-to-nail, all-risks basis covering packing, handling and transit, with exclusions for war, strikes, riots, confiscation, nuclear, chemical, biological and radioactive perils, and wear and tear. Confirm with the insurer, before the sale closes, the length of the automatic cover and the value it applies to the lot.

### Can I send a painting by a standard parcel service?

Read the carrier's terms first. The UPS terms and conditions of carriage for Europe and the United Kingdom list works of art and antiques among the prohibited articles of unusual value. A work sent in breach of those terms leaves the sender with a weak claim if it is lost. A fine art shipper, or a carrier that accepts a declared value in writing, keeps the shipment inside the contract.

## How LLB Auction prepares a buyer for the journey home

LLB Auction is a full service auction house for fine art and collectibles at 29 rue du Fort Elisabeth, L-1463 Luxembourg, with prices in euros and terms under Luxembourg law. Three parts of its practice give a buyer the documents a transit claim rests on.

**Examination before the sale.** The specialist examines every object in person before it goes to sale. A buyer who compares the work on arrival with its lot page compares it with an object the house has seen and handled.

**Conditions stated sale by sale.** Sales are held online on llb-auction.com and listed on Interenchères. The buyer's premium is stated in the conditions of each sale, and the payment, collection and shipping steps are set out on the [how-to-buy page](/how-to-buy) before the first bid.

**A published record.** Each sale has a public results page, gathered on the [auction results page](/results), which lists each lot offered and the hammer price of each lot sold. Buyers with a question on a lot reach the house on WhatsApp and by phone at +352 661 225 970.

A collector new to the format will find the full sequence of a sale, from registration to settlement, in the guide to [how online art auctions work](/insights/the-saleroom/how-auctions-work).

## Conclusion

The rules that decide a transit loss were written long before the November 2026 incidents, and they will outlast them. A road carrier owes 8.33 SDR per kilogram and an air carrier 26 SDR, figures that turn a €5,000 painting into a claim of a few hundred euros at most. The conditions of sale fix when the risk becomes yours, and EU consumer law adds a rule tied to physical possession and to the choice of carrier. Insurance at an agreed value is the only cover sized to the work.

The buyer's part fits on a single page: read the risk clause before bidding, choose the route and the carrier before the lot leaves, insure at the price paid, and at the door write reservations, photograph everything and notify in writing within seven days by road or 14 days by air. Followed in that order, those steps turn artwork damaged in transit from a loss you absorb into a claim you can make.

**Also worth reading:**

- [How online art auctions work](/insights/the-saleroom/how-auctions-work)
- [What happens after winning a lot: invoice, VAT, customs and the insured journey home](/insights/the-saleroom/how-auctions-work/after-the-hammer-invoicing-vat-customs-and-the-insured-journey-home)
- [Art export licence: what a collector needs before a work leaves Europe](/insights/the-saleroom/how-auctions-work/art-export-licence-what-a-collector-needs-before-a-work-leaves-europe)
- [Art auction terms for beginners, from catalogue to crate](/insights/the-saleroom/how-auctions-work/from-catalogue-to-crate-the-stages-a-lot-passes-through)

**Sources:**

- [Directive 2011/83/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council on consumer rights, Articles 2, 16 and 20 and recital 24](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32011L0083): Official Journal of the European Union, 22 November 2011
- [Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR), Articles 17, 23, 26 and 30](https://unece.org/fileadmin/DAM/trans/conventn/cmr_e.pdf): United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, 19 May 1956
- [Protocol to the Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR)](https://www.jus.uio.no/english/services/library/treaties/07/7-02/contract-carriage-road.html): University of Oslo Faculty of Law, treaty text of 5 July 1978
- [Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air, Articles 22 and 31](https://www.mcgill.ca/iasl/files/iasl/montreal1999.pdf): McGill University Institute of Air and Space Law, text of 28 May 1999
- [International air travel liability limits set to increase, enhancing customer compensation](https://www.icao.int/news/international-air-travel-liability-limits-set-increase-enhancing-customer-compensation-0): International Civil Aviation Organization, 18 October 2024
- [Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) in Case C-258/16, Finnair](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:62016CJ0258): Court of Justice of the European Union, 12 April 2018
- [SDR Valuation](https://www.imf.org/external/np/fin/data/rms_sdrv.aspx): International Monetary Fund, 18 November 2026
- [UPS Terms and Conditions of Carriage, Europe and United Kingdom](https://assets.ups.com/adobe/assets/urn:aaid:aem:5e3cccff-6cab-4041-bfe4-5ab774846ae6/original/as/terms-carriage-eur-gb-en.pdf): UPS, 2026
- [Insurance Insights: Fine Art Insurance: Protecting Cultural and Financial Assets](https://www.aca.lu/en/insurance-insights-fine-art-insurance-protecting-cultural-and-financial-assets/): ACA Luxembourg, 16 July 2026
- [Jean Arp Sculpture Worth $160,000 Stolen at Art Cologne](https://news.artnet.com/market/jean-arp-sculpture-worth-160000-stolen-at-art-cologne-2836171): Artnet News, 13 November 2026
- [Silver dealer raises concerns about theft in transit when shipping items from overseas](https://www.antiquestradegazette.com/news/): Antiques Trade Gazette, 18 November 2026
- [How to buy at LLB Auction](https://www.llb-auction.com/how-to-buy): LLB Auction, consulted 19 November 2026